Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…
Recalled by Crystal Temptations
Food recall
Crystal Temptations
Class II — moderate
Using this product might cause a temporary or medically reversible health problem. The chance of serious harm is low.
Crystal Temptations has recalled Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…, according to data published by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The recall was reported on November 11, 2026 and was initiated on August 24, 2026. It is classified as a Class II recall, which means using this product might cause a temporary or medically reversible health problem. The chance of serious harm is low.
Below is a plain-English summary of what was recalled, why it was recalled, how to tell whether you have the affected product, and what steps you can take. For the complete and most current details, you can view the FDA record linked further down this page.
What was recalled?
This recall covers Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…, with approximately 55, 048 pieces affected. The company behind the recall is Crystal Temptations, based in North Arlington, NJ. The FDA describes the product as: “Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolatey Eyeballs ) Spooks and Spells, The product comes in the following sizes: Card Header Bag - 10 oz. Acrylic Box - 7 oz. Eyeball Jar - 10.5 oz. Pouch Bag 16 oz. Tag & Bell Bag 11 oz. . Packaged…”
Why was Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate… recalled?
According to the FDA, the stated reason for the recall is: “Product packaging mix-up. Product containing whey (milk), were distributed in packaging that did not reveal the presence of milk.”
What should you do?
If you think you may have bought Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…, compare it against the product description and identifying codes (CARD HEADER BAG 2022602, 2022604, 2022610, 2142611, 217610, 2172627 ACRYLIC BOX 1222626 EYEBALL JAR 1222626 POUCH BAG 2112618, 2172607, 2172633, 2172639, 22426…) before using it. This recall is currently listed as ongoing.
The general guidance for a matching product is to stop using it and follow the instructions in the official FDA recall notice, which may include a repair, replacement, refund, or safe disposal. When in doubt, contact Crystal Temptations or your local health authority.
About this recall
This recall was distributed in NJ. RecallRadar summarizes recall information from public FDA data to make it easier to understand. We are an independent service and are not affiliated with the FDA or any government agency, so please always refer to the official source for the authoritative record — and note the “last synced” date shown on this page, since recall details can change over time.
Who this recall affects
This recall matters to anyone who bought Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…. Even if you feel fine, it's worth checking what you have on hand rather than assuming you were missed.
Distribution listed in the notice: AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY.
How to check whether you have it
On packaged food, lot codes and best-by dates are usually printed in small date-coding ink on the side seam, the bottom of the package, or near the top seal — not on the front label. The UPC barcode is on the back or bottom.
Compare what you find against the identifying details in this recall: CARD HEADER BAG 2022602, 2022604, 2022610, 2142611, 217610, 2172627 ACRYLIC BOX 1222626 EYEBALL JAR 1222626 POUCH BAG 2112618, 2172607, 2172633, 2172639, 2242601 TAG & BELL BAG 1222626
What to do if you already bought it
Do not eat the product, even if it looks and smells normal — contamination is usually invisible.
Return it to the store for a refund, or throw it away in a sealed bag so pets and wildlife can't reach it.
If it touched other food or surfaces, wash those surfaces and your hands with hot soapy water. When in doubt, contact Crystal Temptations or your local health department.
Full recall details
- Status
- Ongoing
- Date reported
- November 11, 2026
- Recall started
- August 24, 2026
- Distributed in
- NJ
What you can do
Check whether any product you have matches the description and codes above. If it does, stop using it and follow the instructions in the official recall notice. When in doubt, contact the company or your local health authority.
Quick answers
Why was Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate… recalled?+
According to the FDA: Product packaging mix-up.
How serious is this recall?+
Class II — moderate. Using this product might cause a temporary or medically reversible health problem. The chance of serious harm is low.
What should I do if I have Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolate…?+
Compare your product against the description and identifying codes on this page. If it matches, stop using it and follow the instructions in the official recall notice — this usually means returning it for a refund or discarding it. When in doubt, contact the company or your local health authority.
Opens the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) data for this recall.
Recall number: H-0189-2027. Information last synced from the FDA on November 22, 2026.